The Target range of
Doctor Who novelizations are famous for not actually adapting An Unearthly Child until the 1980s. Terrance Dicks chose to novelize the story
before the 1983 anniversary special and surprisingly breathed some life into a
story that was initially flat on broadcast.
The first part of the televised story is as perfect as an episode can be
and Dicks’ novelization was simply taking the episode and writing it in novel
form while adding in some of the thoughts of the characters which you can’t get
when watching a television script. He
even manages to characterize the policeman seen wandering through the fog at
the beginning of the story. When we
actually get to Parts Two, Three and Four, Dicks still goes with the standard
novelization, differing on two main points.
First we learn more of the backstory of the tribe with Za’s father being
killed while hunting and the Old Woman being a superstitious old bat. Second when Za gets himself attacked by a
tiger Dicks actually details the attack whereas on television they never could
have had enough of a budget to decently portray a saber tooth tiger without
completely blowing the budget right out of the water. The novel also doesn’t suffer from the pacing
problems of the original as everything is limited to about 90 pages or so to
keep everything snappy.
To summarize, Doctor Who and an Unearthly Child is a
definite improvement on the original story and Terrance Dicks’ writing style
makes it easy to get through the tedium of the original plot. Nowhere near perfect, but definitely an
engaging read for everything to work out in.
75/100
No comments:
Post a Comment