Justin Richards
being regarded as a safe Doctor Who novelist means that choosing him to
wrap up the hanging threads of the BBC Books in Sometime Never… makes
perfect sense. Doctor Who had
just been commissioned for an official revival and the novelization of The Scream
of the Shalka webcast was coming the very next month. History was repeating for the original Doctor
Who novels, as it became clear that the continuing adventures of the Eighth
Doctor would be coming to an end after the eventual slowdown. The publication schedule had already reduced
from monthly to bimonthly in 2002 and after this novel there are six further
adventures before the range concludes.
The Eighth Doctor and Fitz would appear in one further Past Doctor
Adventures novel, Fear Itself, but that was placed earlier in the
timeline indicating a new status quo that would be cut even more short by the
ending of the Past Doctor Adventures range in 2005. The publication of Sometime Never…
despite being from the reliable Richards was not an easy task, there is a
moment where it is clear the Daleks were meant to appear but the Terry Nation
estate refused the rights, something that was already plaguing the plans for the
revived television series. That backdrop
is the root of this novel’s problems, the BBC Books editorial team obviously
did their best to oversee everything, however, there is a sense throughout that
Richards wanted to push the envelope further than what ended up on the page.
The Council
of Eight is a group of eight entities, possibly representing the specter of the
Time Lords, who have been manipulating the timelines since The Ancestor Cell,
in a non-linear way. There have been several
novels where companions who should not be dead have been killed and this is
revealed to be part of the machinations of the Council of Eight. There is the obvious parallel between the
members of the Council and the incarnations of the Doctor, this parallel going further
by paralleling all nine with Sabbath who is working with mysterious allies, intended
to be the Daleks. The parallels are quite
deep, by the end of the novel there is this implication that the head of the Council,
Soul, with the Doctor’s adopted granddaughter Zezanne become the Doctor and
Susan Foreman from a certain point of view.
Richards is writing the end of Doctor Who as the beginning of Doctor
Who. Oddly enough this is once again
another instance of the revival taking some of its ideas directly from this
novel for how the show actually would end in 2025 (at least the current
incarnation). Were this the end of the
Eighth Doctor Adventures while the lack of the Daleks was disappointing, it
would actually work as a thematic ending.
The ending has the same level of metatext as the final monologue in Survival,
that the Doctor will continue albeit in a different form from what we are used
to. This ending also examines how much
the Eighth Doctor has gone through and deviated from that starting point, being
directly in conversation with the other version of the Eighth Doctor as
presented by Big Finish Productions.
While the Council
of Eight are the primary antagonist and Sabbath is an immoral figure
representing where the Doctor is, there’s actually a lot of levity in Sometime
Never…. The setup of the novel is
the Doctor, Fitz, and Trix all in three separate time periods dealing in part
with historical mysteries, both real and fictional. They each take on different identities and Trix
and Fitz have the beginnings of a romance with a lot of potential. Trix and Fitz are both larger than life
characters who have gone through their own amount of hardship, though Fitz getting
a romance that has the trajectory to be healthy and happy does feel slightly
like giving a male character a love interest a reward through hardship due to
the comedic nature of his failing relationships before this point. It’s easy to overlook this, however, as Fitz
and Trix just banter off one another quite well, especially whenever Richards
has Trix reveal herself as being in disguise.
Having established the character in Time Zero certainly helps Trix’s
appearance here feel as one of her stronger appearances, but this is also
Richards’ ability to tie as many threads as he possibly can together.
Overall,
there was no way that Sometime Never… would be completely satisfying, it
was a book that tied practically every important loose thread for the Eighth
Doctor Adventures because the range is coming to an end. It’s the external factors that are creating a
lack of clarity for essentially what Sabbath especially actually meant or
needed, leaving the character for semi-official spin-off material partially
back in the hands of his creator Lawrence Miles. The ideas are there and it does serve as an
ending, yet it does not end. The story
goes on. 7/10.





