“Unification, Part I” is written by: Jeri Taylor, from
a story by: Rick Berman and Michael Piller, and is directed by: Les Landau. It was produced under production code 208,
was the 7th episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 5,
the 107th episode overall, and was broadcast on November 4, 1991.
The fifth season of Star Trek: The Next Generation
coincided with the franchise’s 25th anniversary. While Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered
Country served as the main anniversary celebration, Rick Berman and Michael
Piller collaborated to produce Unification, a two-part story celebrating
the franchise and coaxing Leonard Nimoy back to play Spock on television for
one last time. It’s Spock’s involvement
with “Unification Part I” that is perhaps the oddest element, his appearance
being saved for a cliffhanger reveal of Picard and Data discovering Spock on
Romulus, exactly where they expected to find him. The tension of the episode is surrounding the
idea of Spock defecting from the Federation to join the Romulans for mysterious
purposes, but the cliffhanger treats Spock’s presence on Romulus as a twist and
not the setup of the episode. This is
not as effectively communicated in the cliffhanger as Jeri Taylor intended,
though it was Berman and Piller’s decision to not have Spock appear properly
until the end of the first episode, so the budget could accommodate Nimoy’s
appearance and schedule to limit his appearance largely to a single episode. This episode was produced after “Unification
Part II” wrapped filming even if the scripts were ready at the same time, again
accommodating Nimoy’s schedule. The
mystery as to why Spock is on Romulus is enough to sustain the entire episode
in terms of driving the plot forward, however, the cliffhanger not playing into
that idea in any major capacity does not adequately create intrigue to bring
the audience back for more.
Jeri Taylor as a writer has a talent for working from
somebody else’s brief while still bringing her own flair to an episode. “Unification Part I” spends much of its time
examining the cultures of the Federation before it can even get to Romulus as a
setting, Taylor being tasked with exploring how the Enterprise can get
there before the rest of the story can begin proper in the second half. Taylor uses this to the script’s advantage by
being contemplative, the character exploration is in service to the larger plot
as the first set piece is on Vulcan followed by a second in the Klingon Empire
before finally getting to Romulus as the conclusion. There is a B-plot in the background of Riker
investigating the debris of a Ferengi ship which seems to be built around the
remains of a lost Vulcan ship, the T’Pau named for the character in “Amok
Time”. This B-plot is also not resolved,
instead Taylor leaving it not on a cliffhanger, just adding an action set piece
between the Enterprise and an unknown enemy vessel to have a tighter
climax. The B-plot is still contributing
thematically to the episode, exploring cultures that do not appear here through
what they leave behind and how they interact: the Vulcans and Ferengi having no
real need to interact with one another, however that is where some secret is to
be found.
While the Federation takes the antagonistic position
of implying Spock as a defector the Vulcan set piece is an exploration of the
father/son relationship between Sarek, played by Mark Lenard, and Spock as
estranged. Lenard plays Sarek as
deteriorating quickly, eventually dying off-screen with the knowledge that
Picard is going to likely help his son in something. The estrangement makes sense; it’s presented
as the intersection and impasse of logic and emotion with how the Federation is
dealing with the Cardassian issue. This
is done between Lenard’s performance opposite Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard
as Sarek and Spock do not meet in this episode, Sarek dies before being able to
reconcile with his son though the episode implies that reconciliation is
unnecessary. He does not believe his son
has turned traitor and pleads with Picard to bring him home because Spock is a
man of principles. Lenard’s final scene
has emotion take the man in a declaration of fatherly pride that as a
full-blooded Vulcan he could only give in moments like this. Taylor’s script use Picard in these scenes as
the representation of rationalizing these emotions due to their mind meld in
“Sarek” creating that deeper connection between the men. Stewart is great at playing this comforting
presence who understands the nuances of losing yourself to aging and illness
all at the same time, continuing the thread from “Sarek” of Sarek’s own dignity
and suffering. There is also a
particularly great role for Joanna Miles as Perrin, playing her as a caring
wife who only wishes to see her husband’s pain end.
This is in complete contrast with the Klingon sequence
of the episode where Picard’s diplomatic and manipulative skills are put to
particular use. Manipulating history for
the general public is the idea at the center of this stretch of the plot,
Gowron not appearing in the episode while actively rewriting recent Klingon
history to remove the Federation and Picard’s part in it. Picard uses this as blackmail so he and Data
can acquire a ship to infiltrate Romulus under the cover of disguise with a
Klingon crew, separating the pair from the Enterprise for the back half
of the episode. This is where Taylor is
active in exploring the parallels between the Klingons and the Romulans, both
used in the original series of Star Trek as allegories for the enemies
of the United States during the Cold War.
Even with the Klingons integrating themselves with the Federation while
still having just enough independence to fully preserve their society, they are
still susceptible to issues of isolationism that have gripped the Romulans. That’s why Gowron is rewriting the recent
history, that and as a ploy to cement his own power, to make the empire stand
tall which is presented as preview for what happens on Romulus. Romulus is presented as a state of paranoid
authoritarianism. There are only a few
scenes set on the planet, with the highlight being Stewart and Brent Spiner
disguised fully as Romulans. The makeup
job does make the pair close to unrecognizable, especially Stewart who is
wearing full wig while Spiner being outside of the white synthetic skin makeup
for Data feels just a little odd intentionally.
Taylor focuses very little on the big picture of Romulus, allowing the
authoritarian background details to sneak in for the viewer. There is one senator as a potential ally,
Pardek played by Malachai Thorne, but the people on the street keep to
themselves while being equally nosy of potential dissidents. It’s the society where the real culmination
of “Unification Part I” can occur and not the cliffhanger.
Overall, it’s the attention to character and
worldbuilding that make “Unification Part I” such an interesting episode. This is an episode that is most concerned
with laying the groundwork for an explosive anniversary experience even if it
arguably ends with the story’s inciting incident. It’s not steeped in nostalgia, while Leonard
Nimoy gets one scene, it’s scenes where actors such as Patrick Stewart and Mark
Lenard are building on previous appearances in Star Trek: The Next
Generation specifically that work for the best. 8/10.





