Doctor Who and the Time Warrior
was written by Terrance Dicks, based on The Time Warrior by: Robert
Holmes. It was the 42nd story
to be novelized by Target Books.
It’s sometimes a shame when a Terrance Dicks book doesn’t
add much new to the original story and that’s essentially what happens with Doctor
Who and the Time Warrior, adapting The Time Warrior. While the book, and indeed the audiobook
narrated by Jeremy Bulloch, does have all the charm of a Terrance Dicks book,
this one seems almost like it was rushed.
With Dicks’ other works you can get a sense that care is taken to see
what can be done to translate from screen to page and enrich some of the text
with that usual charm. For instance, Doctor
Who and the Auton Invasion and Doctor Who and the Terror of the Autons
both introduce new companions from their television stories and give them their
own internal monologues and lives, as well as giving the villains of those
stories some more depth.
Here, this is just a one to one translation of the television
story onto the page except for the prologue.
The prologue is the only thing that deviates, showing Linx crashing into
the Milky Way and eventually the Earth which does give the reader something
about the Sontarans and Rutans which is great, but this was actually from the
mind of Robert Holmes. Holmes originally
wished to write this book himself, but apparently only submitted three pages
before Dicks was brought in to actually write the book. There isn’t any indication that he was
rushed, but outside of some very minor character notes, with the Doctor and the
Brigadier having more interactions at the beginning, it feels like Dicks may
have been rushed.
Overall, Doctor Who and the Time Warrior is
simply inferior to its television counterpart, with the major issues coming
from the fact that it doesn’t change enough to actually feel like a novelization. All of the dialogue feels reproduced from the
television story, which is very possible as it was released only four years from
the initial broadcast so the tapes were there to watch. It’s still decent, The Time Warrior is
a great story even if this isn’t a great adaptation. 7/10.
No comments:
Post a Comment